Before day one of their road trip ends, Mark and Scott make room for one more crazy pizza concoction. For their final slice of the day, Scott and Mark make a stop in Scott’s native New Jersey to visit the oldest family owned pizzeria in the United States, Papa’s Tomato Pie. Established in 1912, their mustard pie is a local favorite, made with a thin layer of mustard between the crust, cheese, and tomato sauce. Will this mustard pie pass Mark’s pizza test? Whose idea was it to put mustard on a pizza in the first place? And where are Scott and Mark going to sleep tonight?

What makes a pizza, a pizza? Lucali owner and oldschool Brooklyn pizzaiolo Mark Iacono has a strict pizza formula: sauce, cheese, and dough. That’s it. But renowned pizza enthusiast Scott Wiener believes that the beauty of the slice comes from its creative customizability; even if it’s topped with cheeseburgers or constructed with paella. Scott travels all over America to spotlight the country’s most unique pies and make a case for whether these new customizations can, in fact, still be considered a pizza. This time, he’s taking Mark along for the ride on an East Coast road trip to try the craziest concoctions claiming to be pizza... but are they really dough?

Credits:

Hosts
Scott Wiener
Mark Iacono

Guest
Nick Azzaro

Featuring
Mike Hauke as Tony Boloney

Showrunner
Keith Cecere

Senior Producer
Chas Truslow

Producer
Phoebe Melnick

Director of Photography
Gunsel Pehlivan

Camera Operator
Carrie Stalk
Corey Stein

Assistant Camera
Lucas Young

Production Audio
Nathan Bonetto

Senior Editor
Chris Murphy

Editor
Morgan Dopp

Associate Editor
Ede Bell Crowder

Colorist
Thomas McKenna

Post Audio
Daniel Byrne

Animators
Fredy Delgado
Megan Chong

Voice Over Artist
Rick Hardy

Illustrator
Jason Hoffman

Photographer
Cole Saladino

Photo Director
Drew Swantak

Production Coordinator
Myra Rivera

Production Assistants
Chanel Baker
Shepherd Overcash
Jennifer Fullante

Programming Coordinator
Madeline Concannon

Line Producer
Emily Tufaro

Director of Development
Leo Fernandez

PostProduction Supervisor
Daniel Byrne

Supervising Producer
Stasia Jones

Design Director
Ted McGrath

Executive Producer
Justin Lundstrom

Subscribe to Thrillist    / @thrillist  

Check out our website for more food, drink, travel, and entertainment.
https://www.thrillist.com

Like us on Facebook
  / thrillist  

Follow us on Instagram
  / thrillist  

Sign up for our newsletter
https://signup.thrillist.com/

#Thrillist #ReallyDough #NewJersey