The officers who arrived at the Suffolk County home of Valerie Cincinelli in 2019 were there to share devastating news with the thenNYPD officer: her estranged husband and the father of her child was dead. But prosecutors said it was all an act. Cincinelli wasn't surprised to hear her husband was dead because she orchestrated a chilling murderforhire plot to kill him. And the police's arrival at Cincinelli's doorstep wasn't really on the heels of his death, but instead part of a sting operation.