"Annie"'s original Annie, Andrea McArdle, tries on "Annie"'s other female lead, Miss Hannigan. Long Beach, CA. 2010, with Michael Paternostro and Bets Malone. See Nell Carter as Hannigan at • NELL CARTER "Annie" '97 "Little Girls... and • NELL CARTER's extra ANNIE song . See Sutton Foster as Star to Be in "Annie" '97 at • SUTTON FOSTER as "Star to Be" in ANNI...